# Case study: Blue Tree Nutrition. Google AI's first answer. ChatGPT's first choice. Second in Gemini.

Blue Tree Nutrition (bluetreenutrition.com) is the practice of Valerie Polley, a registered dietitian in Zionsville, Indiana, serving the greater Carmel area. She works with digestive issues and elimination diets and accepts major insurance plans. The practice runs on a WordPress site. Selecta made it readable by AI assistants on August 27, 2026. The owner did not touch anything.

- Client: Blue Tree Nutrition, https://bluetreenutrition.com
- Platform: WordPress
- AI-Ready setup by Selecta: August 27, 2026
- Score on Cloudflare's public scanner (isitagentready.com): 43 before, 86 after, Level 5, Agent-Native

## What was wrong

Before the work, Cloudflare's scanner scored the site 43 out of 100, Level 1, Basic Web Presence. Half of the discovery checks failed (Discoverability 50). There was no plain-language version of the site for AI to read (Content 0). AI crawlers had no clear welcome signal (Bot Access 50). An assistant asked about a nutritionist near Carmel had little to go on.

## What Selecta did

- A plain-language version of the site written for AI (llms.txt and a Markdown copy), built from the real pages: who Valerie is, what she treats, the insurance she accepts, where she is, how to book
- Content Signals for AI crawlers and search engines in robots.txt
- Link headers that point assistants to the right files, and Markdown content negotiation
- Verification from outside the site, the way an AI agent sees it
- Both scan reports, before and after, delivered with a plain-language note

The site's look did not change.

## The score

- Before: 43, Level 1, Basic Web Presence. Discoverability 50, Content 0, Bot Access Control 50.
- After: 86, Level 5, Agent-Native. Discoverability 75, Content 100, Bot Access Control 100.

## What AI assistants say now (checked September 6, 2026)

Question asked: "is there a good nutritionist near the Greater Carmel, Indiana area you can recommend"

- Google AI Overview: starts with "You can visit Blue Tree Nutrition for specialized digestive and custom eating plans in the Carmel area." Lists the practice first, names Valerie Polley, her specialty and the insurance she takes. Both cited sources are pages from bluetreenutrition.com.
- Gemini: lists Blue Tree Nutrition second, with a 5.0 rating, and describes it in its own words: located just nearby in Zionsville, serving the greater Carmel-Zionsville community with expert dietary planning and counseling.
- ChatGPT: lists Blue Tree Nutrition first under "My top picks" and calls it "my first choice" for digestive and GI issues. Names Valerie Polley, RDN, her 20+ years of experience, her Zionsville office, virtual visits and the insurance she takes, cited to bluetreenutrition.com.

AI answers change over time and by location. Selecta does not promise a ranking. Selecta makes a site readable so AI can quote it.

## Get this for your site

AI-Ready by Selecta: from $350 USD, one time, no subscription, done in days. Scan your site for free at https://selectawebs.com/ or email hello@selectawebs.com with your website address.

Related: Pilates One Hundred case study, https://selectawebs.com/work/pilates-one-hundred